Second Paper

December 1st, 2011

Subject : # 14159 Curs Monográfic: Shakespeare through Performance

Student’s name: Badía Torrente, Leticia   (lele.blogs.uv.es)

Title of the paper: “Love and Marriage in Much Ado About Nothing, The Taming of the Shrew and Twelfth Night”

Author or topic: William Shakespeare

Abstract:

This paper explores the theme of love and marriage in the comedies The Taming of the Shrew (1593-94), Much Ado About Nothing (1598) and Twelfth Night (1601). It is divided once again into two sections: the first part contains an analysis of the main female characters in the three plays, relating their behaviour to the social norms of Elizabethan time – classifying them as either rebellious or conforming to the rules – and comparing their romances to the popular practise of courtly love. This analysis serves as a good basis for the second part of the paper, which covers the topic of marriage itself, with a study of attitudes towards its meaning (the importance of wealth and social classes), and a description of the steps required to formalize it.

Table of contents:

1. Shakespeare’s heroines

a) The active women

b) The shrews

c) The weak…or not?

2. Marriage

a) The importance of social class

3. The steps towards marriage

a) Wooing and courting

b) Marriage as an economic institution: dowries and jointures

c) The spousal

d) The ceremony

Conclusion

Bibliography

Auto-evaluation:

Notable

Academic year 2011/2012
© a.r.e.a./Dr.Vicente Forés López
© Leticia Badía Torrente
lele@alumni.uv.es

1. Shakespeare’s heroines

December 1st, 2011

There are four women in the three plays analyzed that do not fall into the category of mild Elizabethan women. They are Beatrice from Much Ado About Nothing, Viola and Olivia from Twelfth Night and Katherine from The Taming of the Shrew.

a) The active women

Viola would be the less strong of the group. Although she doesn’t have the wit or aggressiveness of other heroines such as Beatrice, she takes an active role throughout the play and shows her adaptability and resourcefulness, first by disguising herself as a boy to overcome the obstacles of her sex, and second in her role of Cesario, the messenger who woos Olivia on behalf of the passive Orsino. Just like Beatrice got carried over by emotion and was ready to depart from her “maiden pride” (III.1.109) and let Benedick tame her wild heart, Viola implies that women are the weaker sex after being shocked by Olivia’s confession: “How easy is it for the proper false / In women’s waxen hearts to set their forms! / Alas, our frailty is the cause, not we, / For such as we are made of, such we be.” (II.2.29-32) Still, Viola defends women’s equality when she confronts Orsino after the latter says that women cannot love as deeply as men (II.4.92-109). In the end, Viola proves herself stronger than her twin brother Sebastian, who takes a submissive position around Olivia.

Olivia is not given enough credit as one of Shakespeare’s independent women. The death of her father and brother allows her to be in charge of her household. Her will to marry whoever she wants is not challenged by the imposition of an authoritative male figure, like in Beatrice’s case. Even Sir Toby, who by tradition would have the right to rule the house, doesn’t  dispute her authority. Conventionally, Duke Orsino would be the perfect match for her, for as she says, he is “virtuous”, “noble”, “of great estate, of fresh and stainless youth”, “a gracious person” (I.5.247-51), but she doesn’t love him and rejects his advances. In contrast, the Duke Orsino, also in charge of his house, is portrayed as a passive male figure, who claims to be lovesick but doesn’t take an active role to woo Olivia.

Shakespeare subverts tradition by making Olivia, the woman, the one to pursue the man, Cesario. When Olivia sends her ring to Cesario, she is stepping outside of her passive role. However, this subversion brings chaos, and order is restored only after the gender of her object of desire has been shifted and settled according to convention. Even then, Olivia is still the one in control of Sebastian:

OLIVIA

Nay, come, I prithee, would thou’ldst be ruled by me.

SEBASTIAN

Madam, I will.

OLIVIA

O, say so, and so be.

(IV.1.62-63)

b) The shrews

In Much Ado About Nothing, Beatrice is told be “shrewd of tongue” and to “pass shrewdly”. She is also described as a an “infernal Ate” (2.1.234), an “harpy” (248) and “Lady Tongue” (252) by Benedick, albeit without ill intention in the context of their battle of wits. In The Taming of the Shrew, Katherine is called “rough” (I.1.55), “curst” (177), “stark mad” (69) and a “shrew” (177) outright by men who have just seen her. Katherine could be regarded as an extreme Beatrice, but not without reason: she is frustrated because society expects her to submit herself to the command of a husband who may be no match for her in intelligence and wits. Moreover, she has to suffer her father’s favouritism towards her younger sister, the fair and mild Bianca.

Katherine’s character is among the most complicated to decipher. Like Carolyn E. Brown says, “It seemed so different from the rest of the comedies in which Shakespeare shows appreciation for the woman’s situation” (163). Critics in the 17th century thought that “Catharines Harangue to her Sister and the Widow on the Duty of Wives to their Husbands, if the Ladies wou’d read it with a little Regard, might be of mighty use in this Age” (C. Gildon 39). Nowadays, critics view Katherine either as a victim of social patriarchy, or choose to interpret the play as a farce that subtly criticizes the status of women in the 16th century. Others think that, like Beatrice and Benedick, Katherine and Petruchio are equals in intelligence and wit, and despite the initial quarreling and resistance, their marriage turns out to be the happiest of the three. For example, Harold C. Goddard says that “Kate’s shrewishness is superficial” because she is “‘starved for love”, and that “Petruchio’s procedure at bottom shows insight, understanding, and even love” (109), a view that also holds the critic Harold Bloom, who thinks that “they operate as a couple and are happy because of it, leaving the others disgruntled and envious” (18). Following that line of criticism, the Encyclopedia Britannica describes Much Ado About Nothing as “brilliant rewriting of The Taming of the Shrew”.

c) The weak…or not?

The first appearance of Bianca make us think of Hero. Both of them are contrasted with their older sister and cousin, respectively, and show every sign of being their bland counterpart. Bianca is described in angelic terms: as a “Minerva” (I.1.84), as a “sweet beauty” (164) with “coral lips” who “with her breath she did perfume the air”, “sacred and sweet” (171-173). Actually, Bianca is only like Hero on the outside. She is a “pretty peat” (78), the real shrew. She flirts with all of her suitors, and in the final scene, refuses to come when Lucentio calls her forward. Instead of rebelling against society like her sister, she twists her role so that it benefits her.

2. Marriage

December 1st, 2011

Beatrice enjoyed more freedom than his cousin Hero in Much Ado About Nothing because she did not have a father that urged her into marriage. Twelfth Night is special in that patriarchal figures are completely absent. There is no father that forces Olivia to accept Orsino’s petition. In The Taming of the Shrew, on the other hand, we have a father very interested in marrying his daughters for financial prosperity.

a) The importance of social class

Since marriage consisted in economic and political alliances, marrying outside one’s social class was highly discouraged. It would have been unfortunate for Olivia to marry Cesario, since he is just “the count’s serving-man” (III.2.5), as Aguecheek notes scornfully. Sir Toby makes Aguecheek think that he is a worthy candidate for Olivia because he is wealthy and belongs to the same class as Olivia. However, Aguecheek does not hold high hopes because “The count himself here hard by woos her” (I.3.101). Maria’s prank on Malvolio plays with his ambitions to ascend the scale of the strict Elizabethan social hierarchy. By marrying Olivia, he, a servant, will become “Count Malvolio” (II.5.32).

In Twelfth Night, order is restored in the end when it is revealed that Sebastian and Viola are “right noble” of blood (V.1.258). This discovery validates the marriages of Orsino-Viola and Sebastian-Olivia, but the union of Sir Toby and Maria is still heterodox, maybe following the spirit of the festival of Twelfth Night, in which, “in general, normal constraints and conventions would not apply.” (H.Bloom and P. Loos 29).  Anyhow, “Shakespeare does not seem to approve of this wedlock between a gentleman and a servant, since both are expelled from the stage at the end of the play (when the characters are paired off) (…) Shakespeare clearly wished to close the play with the end of New Year’s festival and the restoration of order in Illyria.” (Fundación Instituto Shakespeare 20, my translation).

3. The steps towards marriage

December 1st, 2011

a) Wooing and courting: parody of courtly love

As in Much Ado About Nothing, Twelfth Night depicts a romance that follows the conventions of courtly love, hinting at the ridiculousness of its excesses.

In the opening speech, Duke Orsino shows himself as a typical Petrarchan lover, a man infatuated not with the woman he loves, but with the idea of loving a virtuous woman. As Gareth Lloyd Evans says, “his first speech has all the languid self-indulgence of a man in an illusion of love” (qtd. in Wells and Warren 25).  His melodramatic attitude and his quick changes of mood suggest that his love is capricious, and that he is just playing the role of a man who is madly in love.

Following the tradition of courtly love, he fell in love with Olivia upon meeting her (I.1.18-22), and even though he hardly knows her, he has been feeling lovesick since that moment. His language is artificial and draws on convention, showering Olivia with compliments. The object of his discourse moves to himself, to whom he compares to the mythical huntsman Actaeon, helpless in his mad love. In the end, it is not the lady that “pursues” him, but his “desires” (I.1.18-22).

Orsino’s pitiable passivity matches Benedick’s comment about the effects of love in Much Ado About Nothing: “seeing how much another man is a fool when he dedicates his behaviors to love” (II.3.7-9).

Orsino keeps on showing this narcissistic, dramatic conduct when he asks Feste to play the song that relieved his passion (II.4.4). Come Away Death is a song about dying from an unrequited love. As the sensible Rosalind states in As You Like It, “The poor world is almost six thousand years old, and in all this time there was not any man died (…) in a love-cause” (IV.1.70-73).

When Cesario goes to woo Olivia on behalf of Orsino, the woman in disguise addresses Olivia by the clichéd “Most radiant, exquisite, and unmatchable beauty” (I.5.62). However, Olivia pays attention to her only when she has dropped her artificial language and broke into an inappropriate remark (“if this be the lady of the house, for I never saw her”, 163-64), which mirrors her likewise offensive initial question (“The honourable lady of the house, which is she?”, 160). Like Benedick and Beatrice, they are equal in wit, and prefer to speak without artifices. Olivia proceeds to discredit the Duke’s flowery language by remarking its frivolous nature:

VIOLA

But this is from my commission. I will on with my speech in your praise, and then show you
the heart of my message.

OLIVIA

Come to what is important in’t, I forgive you the praise.

VIOLA

Alas, I took great pains to study it, and ’tis poetical.

OLIVIA

It is the more like to be feigned, I pray you keep it in.

(I.5.180-189)

Viola is really adamant in saying that she has studied all of Orsino’s flowery language. As the scene continues, both women keep mocking overwrought language: Viola suggests that Olivia should marry and have children to leave a copy of her beauty in this world, and Olivia proceeds to break down her beauty to a set of items (I.5.228-238). The climax of this mockery is reached when Cesario describes how he would love Olivia in the famous “willow cabin” speech (257-265).

However, Olivia begins to be interested in Cesario after this passionate speech, which greatly counterpoints the Duke’s passivity, who is busy complaining about his lovesickness at home. It is Cesario’s wit, sarcasm and passion that have attracted her to the messenger. That is the reason why, in the end, we are left wondering whether Olivia’s marriage to Sebastian will be successful: Sebastian lacks the wit of her twin sister, and marries Olivia adhering to the conventions of courtly love, i.e. after falling in love at first sight. Critics have argued that their marriage is merely a requirement for a happy ending, while some others relate it to Olivia’s comment of “Love sought is good, but given unsought is better” (II.1.154), and interpret it as not as a “crude ending”, but “rather, [Sebastian] ‘recognizes the power of chance and good fortune in affairs of love’.” (M.M. Mahood 12, quote comes from Gl’Ingannati, one of Shakespeare’s source plays for the plot).

In the end, both Viola and Olivia have mocked the excessive passions of courtly love, but both of them have fallen victims to it: Viola has fallen in love with Orsino in a few days, and Olivia has fallen in love with Cesario in less than an hour (“Even so quickly may one catch the plague?”, I.5.285) It can be concluded that love passions cannot be taken too seriously, and that they merely fleeting emotions, “much ado about nothing”. It needs to be remembered that the two character in Much Ado About Nothing who scorned courtly love also flirted with its practices, such as the writing of sonnets.

This whole idea is exemplified more clearly in the comic subplot, the gulling of Malvolio. The quatrain written by Maria is a parody of Elizabethan love poems, “more intent on displaying ingenuity than on expressing feeling” (Wells and Warren 50). The yellow stockings and the cross-garterings, used to ridicule Malvolio, are a symbol of traditional lovers.

In The Taming of the Shrew, courtly love is not shown so much as a parody, but as a type of short-lived love that does not bring happiness in marriage. Lucentio falls in love at first sight with the perfect Bianca, and Bianca grows interested in the young and wealthy Lucentio. Like Hero and Claudio, they are naive, their love immature.

b) Marriage as an economic institution: dowries and jointures

The economic motivation for marriage is seen in more detail in The Taming of the Shrew. In Much Ado About Nothing, Claudio fell in love with Hero knowing her as Leonato’s daughter, and showed interest in knowing whether she was the only heir of his fortunes. Likewise, in Twelfth Night, the first thing Olivia does after growing interested in Cesario is enquiring about his parentage (I.5.267).  In The Taming of the Shrew, Shakespeare shows us the negotiation between the father and the suitors.

Like Benedick said he wouldn’t marry Beatrice “though she were endowed with all that Adam bad left him before he transgressed” (2.1.229-231), Gremio says that  “I had as lief take her dowry with this condition – to be whipped at the high cross every morning” (I.1.129-131). Dowry is a prize that comes along with the “commodity”, the wife. Petruchio barges in looking for a rich wife, with no regards to her physic or personality. He is only after the dowry: “I come to wive it wealthily in Padua; If wealthily, then happily in Padua”. Since Baptista’s oldest “commodity” (II.1.321) is a shrew, the prize needs to be higher so that she can be sold. That’s why Baptista offers Petruchio the large dowry of half of his lands plus 20,000 crowns (II.1.121-2).

The jointure was the inheritance which the widow would receive upon his husband’s death. Baptista auctions off Bianca to Gremio and Tranio, who is pretending to be Lucentio, so that Lucentio himself can pass as a tutor and woo Bianca. As Baptista says, he is playing the “merchant’s part” (II.1.329). Katherine compares this transaction to the hiring of whores (“I pray you, sir, is it your will / to make a stale of me amongst these mates?”, I.1.57-8). Baptista chooses Lucentio because he has bidden the highest (II.1.335-81). Petruchio’s generous jointure is accepted as well (123-5).

Once dowry and jointure are fixed, the contract is signed (II.1.126), and the father hands his daughter to her new husband. The daughter moves from being a property of her father to being a property of her husband, as Petruchio says: “I will be master of what is mine own. / She is my goods, my chattels; she is my house, / My household stuff, my field, my barn, / My horse, my ox, my ass, my any thing,” (II.2.228-31).

c) The spousal

As we saw in the previous paper, betrothal had to be conducted in front of witnesses, and a verbal contract in which both spouses were present was enough to make the contract irrevocable. In the three plays, the spousal is made per verba de praesenti. Sometimes Shakespeare substituted words for gestures that indicated agreement, like with Hero’s kiss or Katherine’s silence. The rest of the couples, such as Sebastian-Olivia and Orsino-Viola, exchange words of willingness before the ceremony.

The crying of the banns is not present in Twelfth Night due to Olivia and Sebastian’s hasty marriage, and the fact that the play ends before the ceremony of the wedding between Orsino and Viola takes place. It is mentioned in The Taming of the Shrew (“I’ll crave the day / When I shall ask the banns, and when be married”, II.1.179-80), but the actual practice of calling the banns for three consecutive Sundays is not respected, probably because it would be anticlimactic (in Much Ado About Nothing, if this had been respected, Hero’s shaming would have taken place before the ceremony and wouldn’t have been as dramatic).

d) The ceremony and consummation

Weddings were usually celebrated on Sunday at the church porch. Wealthy families spared no expenses in preparing splendid ceremonies to display their status. The spouses and the attendants dressed up in their best robes. When Petruchio does not show up on time and, when he turns up, he is dressed poorly and riding a crippled horse, he is not only offending Kate, but also Baptista, who wonders what other people will think of his family (III.2.4). Likewise, Olivia says that she will celebrate a public wedding, even though she has already married Sebastian in secret, “according to [her] birth” (IV.3.31).

As said in the previous paper, the Act of Uniformity of 1559 made mandatory the use of the Prayer Book in ceremonies. Refusing to use the book was punished with sanctions such as life imprisonment. Shakespeare parodies these rites by making some characters act blasfemously during the ceremony. If Leonato interrupted the priest and urged him to go straight to the point, Petruchio takes the impatience to the next level and hits the priest, making him drop the book (III.2.157-63).

A solemn ceremony of marriage, albeit clandestine, is depicted in Twelfth Night:

PRIEST

A contract of eternal bond of love,

Confirm’d by mutual joinder of your hands,

Attested by the holy close of lips,

Strengthen’d by interchangement of your rings,

And all the ceremony of this compact

Sealed in my function, by my testimony:

(V.1.152-7)

Petruchio violates the solemnity of the observance by “[kissing] her lips with such a clamorous smack / That at the parting all the church did echo.” (III.2.177-8)

A feast took place after the ceremony. In Much Ado About Nothing, we saw dancing and gaiety. In The Taming of the Shrew, Petruchio offends the guests when he makes Kate leave the feast with him, despite her wife’s protests. The banquet of Bianca and Lucentio is also represented.

Finally, the last part of marriage was the consummation. We only see this in The Taming of the Shrew, when Petruchio tells Kate: “Come, Kate, we’ll to bed” (V.3.183). Consummation took place in the same day of the wedding, but Petruchio postpones it in his process of “taming” Kate.

4. Conclusion

December 1st, 2011

Love is a central theme on Shakespeare’s comedies, and he has experimented with many different variations. The theme of true love is most important in his earliest comedies, such as The Taming of the Shrew and Much Ado About Nothing. Twelfth Night appears to be the last comedy in which questions about the nature of love are explored.

It is clear that Shakespeare rejected the ritualistic insincerity of courtly love, and made couples that followed this practice fail before or after marriage: Claudio’s neglect of Hero after learning of her alleged unchastity, the post marriage shattered appearances of Lucentio and Bianca, and Orsino’s quick dismissal of Olivia even though he had proclaimed his lovesickness throughout the play. In contrast, couples that had an unconventional romance turn out to be the happiest. Love is most successful between people who are equal in wits, such as Benedick and Beatrice, and Petruchio and Katherine, or in people whose love stems from a base that doesn’t rely on love at first sight, such as is the case of Orsino and Viola.

Bibliography

December 1st, 2011

Bloom, Harold. “Introduction.” The Taming of the Shrew. Ed. Harold Bloom and Pamela Loos. New York: Bloom’s Literary Criticism, 2008. Xi-Xii. Google Books.

Brown, Carolyn E. “Bianca and Petruchio: ‘The Veriest Shrew[s] of All,’”. Re-Visions of Shakespeare: Essays in Honor of Robert Ornstein. 2004. Rpt. in The Taming of the Shrew. Ed. Harold Bloom and Pamela Loos. New York: Bloom’s Literary Criticism, 2008. 163-81. Google Books.

“Encyclopædia Britannica’s Guide to Shakespeare – Romantic Comedies.” Encyclopedia – Britannica Online Encyclopedia. Web. 24 Nov. 2011. <http://www.britannica.com/shakespeare/article-232322>.

Gildon, Charles. Remarks on the Plays of Shakespear. 1709. Rpt. in The Taming of the Shrew. Ed. Harold Bloom and Pamela Loos. New York: Bloom’s Literary Criticism, 2008. 38-39. Google Books.

Goddard, Harold C. “The Taming of the Shrew,.”. The Meaning of Shakespeare. 1951. Rpt. in The Taming of the Shrew. Ed. Harold Bloom and Pamela Loos. New York: Bloom’s Literary Criticism, 2008. Google Books.

Shakespeare, William. Much Ado about Nothing. Ed. Claire McEachern. London: Arden Shakespeare, 2006. Print.

Shakespeare, William. The Taming of the Shrew. Ed. G. R. Hibbard. Harmondsworth, Middlesex: Penguin Books, 1976. Print.

Shakespeare, William. “Introducción  Argumento ” Noche De Reyes, O, Como Queráis. Ed. Fundación Instituto Shakespeare. Madrid: Cátedra, 2000. 16-22. Print.

Shakespeare, William. “Introduction” Twelfth Night. Ed. M. M. Mahood. London: Penguin, 1995. 7-39. Print.

Shakespeare, William. Twelfth Night, Or, What You Will. Ed. Roger Warren and Stanley W. Wells. Oxford: Oxford UP, 1998. Print.

Sokol, B. J., and Mary Sokol. Shakespeare, Law, and Marriage. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge UP, 2003. Print.

“Twelfth Night in the Seventeenth Century.” Twelfth Night. Ed. Harold Bloom and Pamela Loos. New York: Bloom’s Literary Criticism, 2008. 29. Print.

First Paper

October 17th, 2011

Subject :# 14159 Curs Monográfic: Shakespeare through Performance

Student’s name: Badía Torrente, Leticia   (lele.blogs.uv.es)

Title of the paper: “The Institution of Marriage in Much Ado About Nothing”

Author or topic: William Shakespeare

Abstract: For this first paper I have decided to talk about marriage in Elizabethan times, as seen in the play “Much Ado About Nothing”. In order to fully understand the concepts that surround marriage,  I thought it necessary to summarize the most important aspects of the situation of women in that time as well.

The paper is divided into two parts. The first part is preceded by an introduction on the situation of women in Elizabethan times, followed by an analysis of the two main women in the play, the passive Hero and the strong-willed Beatrice, as well as their relationship with Claudio and Benedick, respectively.

The second part deals with the topic of marriage –how it was seen as a transactional contract and why virginity was so important. This second part ends with an explanation of the stages towards marriage, beginning with wooing and ending with the ceremony itself.

Table of contents:

  1. Women in Elizabethan Society
  2. The women in the play
    1. Hero, the perfect woman
    2. The main lovers, Hero and Claudio
    3. Beatrice, the independent woman
    4. The true lovers, Beatrice and Benedick
  3. Basic ideas on marriage: property and virginity
    1. Marriage and property
    2. The importance of virginity
  4. The steps towards marriage: from wooing to the ceremony
    1. Wooing and courting
    2. Arranging marriage
    3. The ceremony and festivities
  5. Conclusion

Bibliography

Auto-evaluation:

Notable

Academic year 2011/2012
© a.r.e.a./Dr.Vicente Forés López
© Leticia Badía Torrente
lele@alumni.uv.es

1. Women in Elizabethan Society

October 17th, 2011

The Elizabethan society was a patriarchal one. Society was ruled by men, and women were not allowed to attend school or university, vote or act in the theatres. Moreover, they could not inherit their father’s titles, except in the monarchy. They needed to be dependent on a male relative, and had to be obedient and dutiful towards their fathers and husbands. Once they married, women became housewives and their most important duty was to give birth to many children.

Benedick provides a full description of the qualities of the perfect Elizabethan girl in Act 2, Scene III:

Rich she shall be, that’s certain; wise,
or I’ll none; virtuous, or I’ll never cheapen her;
fair, or I’ll never look on her; mild, or come not
near me; noble, or not I for an angel; of good
discourse, an excellent musician, and her hair shall
be of what colour it please God.

(2.3.28-32)

The two female main characters in the play portray two diverging attitudes towards male domination and female etiquette. Hero, Leonato’s daughter, represents the figure of the traditionally oppressed woman who conforms to social rules; while Beatrice, Hero’s cousin, embodies a strong-willed woman who rebels against this patriarchy, defending women to be equal to men.

Women were perceived as the weaker sex and were thus educated to be submissive and to accept authority. Religious, biological and social justifications were provided to keep male domination alive.

First, The Church had always subordinated women to men. Adam was created first, followed by Eve, who was created to serve him, and whose attempt to adopt a dominant position resulted in downfall for mankind. The Book of Common Prayer, used regularly by the Anglican church in services and marriages, quoted: “Ye women submit yourselves unto your own husbands as unto the Lord, for the husband is the wife’s head even as Christ is the head of the Church”.

Beatrice argues against this view in Act 2, Scene I, when Leonato expresses his wish to see his niece married:

Not till God make men of some other metal than
earth. Would it not grieve a woman to be
overmastered with a pierce of valiant dust? to make
an account of her life to a clod of wayward marl?
No, uncle, I’ll none: Adam’s sons are my brethren;
and, truly, I hold it a sin to match in my kindred.

(2.1.52-57)

What Beatrice is saying here is that she considers herself equal to men because they were made of the same material, earth, and both are in the end only dust. She revokes this religious justification using religious rhetoric: men and women are God’s children, equals.

Regarding the biological aspect, women “were considered a somewhat more primitive life-form, whose blood, according to Galenic physiology, was colder, and whose metabolism more sluggish in nature than a man’s.” (McEachern 32). Galen’s one-sex theory stated that women and men represented two different forms of the same sex, with the placement of the sexual organs being the main difference. The most abundant humour in women was phlegm, which made them apathetic, passive. Women were thus a more immature version of men. Beatrice comments ironically on Galen’s theory in Act 1, Scene I, when she retorts to Benedick that she too loves no one because of her cold blood and her humour (1.1.123-124).

Lastly, women had to be quiet, because their conversation was not of much quality. As Beatrice says jokingly to Don Pedro:

But, I beseech your grace, pardon me: I
was born to speak all mirth and no matter.

(2.1.303-304)

On the subject of sexuality, cuckoldry jokes are prevalent throughout the play. Men are so afraid of becoming cuckolds because that would mean losing sexual power over women, losing manhood. The jokes emphasize the public display of cuckoldry:

BENEDICK

The savage bull may; but if ever the sensible
Benedick bear it, pluck off the bull’s horns and set
them in my forehead: and let me be vilely painted,
and in such great letters as they write ‘Here is
good horse to hire,’ let them signify under my sign
‘Here you may see Benedick the married man.’

(1.1.244-249)

Cuckolds become visible, an spectacle for the community to mock. By cheating, it is the woman who tells the joke and pushes men into the background. The telling of cuckold jokes restores the man to power.

Due to female power being associated with cuckoldry, women who talk a lot and show signs of intelligence are considered shrews and dangerous, prone to cheating. That’s why Beatrice doubts she will ever marry.

2. The women in the play

October 17th, 2011

2.1. Hero, the perfect woman

(http://www.fanpop.com/spots/much-ado-about-nothing/images/1099791/title/hero-photo)

Hero is everything a perfect Elizabethan woman is expected to be: she is quiet, submissive, sweet, gentle and kind. She is an obedient daughter to Leonato, and an obedient wife to Claudio.

When Claudio meets her for the first time after returning to Messina, he describes her as “a modest young lady” (153), “a jewel” (167) and “the sweetest lady” (173). Even though she is supposed to be one of the main characters of the play, she speaks but few lines, and acts more as a passive object than as an active participant in the events.

Hero performs an active role only on two occasions: first, when she is carrying out the plan to get Benedick and Beatrice together by talking to Ursula about Benedick’s supposed love for her cousin; and second, when she hands to Benedick the sonnet that Beatrice wrote. Neither of these occasions involves her directly.

The times when she ought to speak, she remains silent. She seals her marriage with a kiss, and doesn’t defend herself too vehemently when Claudio wrongs her at their wedding. In the end, she forgives Claudio without a doubt, even when he has brought her so much suffering.

2.1.1. The main lovers, Hero and Claudio

(http://www.movieforum.com/movies/titles/muchadoaboutnothing/heroclaudio.shtml)

Hero and Claudio represent the most traditional couple in the play. Their love may come across as shallow: they get married without knowing each other, and that lack of trust leads Claudio to fall into Don John’s trap of believing that Hero is unchaste. Claudio doesn’t know Hero on the inside, he only knows her façade, the perceptions others have of her, “the sign and semblance of her honour” (4.1.31).

When Don John lures Claudio into thinking that Hero is not worth marrying, Claudio, instead of challenging John in order to defend Hero’s honour, is inclined to believe her bad actions:

If I see anything tonight why I should not
marry her tomorrow, in the congregation,
where I should wed, there will I shame her.

(3.3.111-113)

Later in the play, after Claudio has shamed Hero, the Friar comes up with a plan to make him regret his actions and soften his heart:

And every lovely organ of her life
Shall come apparell’d in more precious habit,
More moving-delicate and full of life,
Into the eye and prospect of his soul,
Than when she lived indeed; then shall he mourn,
If ever love had interest in his liver,
And wish he had not so accused her,
No, though he thought his accusation true.

(4.1.226-233)

But love must not have had interest in his liver, for he reacts coldly when Leonato and Antonio approach him bearing the news of Hero’s death. He denies having anything to do with her death when Leonato says that it was his villany that killed his daughter, and even laughs at their grief: “We had like to have had our two noses snapped off with two old men without teeth.”

Claudio only mourns Hero after she has been completely cleared of all accusations:

Sweet Hero, now thy image doth appear
In the rare semblance that I loved it first.

(5.1.241-242)

He only mourns her when he is sure that she is a virgin. Claudio doesn’t mourn Hero, he mourns the chaste Hero. Had she not been cleared of suspicion, he would not have felt bad for her death.

2.2. Beatrice, the independent woman

(http://www.movieforum.com/movies/titles/muchadoaboutnothing/emma.shtml)

Beatrice is the opposite of her cousin: she is a strong-willed, sharp and independent woman who doesn’t conform to traditional gender roles. If Hero was modest, a jewel and sweet; Beatrice is described by Benedick as an “infernal Ate” (2.1.234), an “harpy” (248) and “Lady Tongue” (252).

She is the first to attack both before and after Benedick and the company are returned to Messina.

Although she is called “Lady Disdain” (1.2.112) and is said to “speak poniards” (2.1.227), she is also vulnerable on the inside. She feels hurt when she hears Hero say about her that “she cannot love, nor take no shape nor project of affection, she is so self-endeared.” (3.1.54-56) It is after she hears that Benedick loves her that she lowers her defenses just a little:

BEATRICE

[Coming forward]
What fire is in mine ears? Can this be true?
Stand I condemn’d for pride and scorn so much?
Contempt, farewell! and maiden pride, adieu!
No glory lives behind the back of such.
And, Benedick, love on; I will requite thee,
Taming my wild heart to thy loving hand:
If thou dost love, my kindness shall incite thee
To bind our loves up in a holy band;
For others say thou dost deserve, and I
Believe it better than reportingly.

(3.1.107-116)

In spite of her independent character, Beatrice resorts to the traditional roles of men and women when Hero is wronged:

BEATRICE

O that I were a man! What, bear her in hand until they
come to take hands; and then, with public
accusation, uncovered slander, unmitigated rancour,
–O God, that I were a man! I would eat his heart
in the market-place.

(4.1.302-305)

A woman was left defenseless if her honour was put into question, but a man would be able to recover by challenging his opponent to a duel. Beatrice regrets being powerless as a woman, because she cannot do anything to help restore Hero’s honour.

But the battle of wits goes on, and Beatrice will still assert her independence. When Benedick and she are talking alone in the balcony, Benedick asks hers with which of his “bad parts” (5.2.56) did she fall in love, while her question changes “bad parts” for “good parts” (5.2.61). Benedick talks about “falling in love” (5.2.57), while she speaks of “suffering love” (5.2.61).

This battle goes one even in the day of the wedding. When Benedick calls her forth at the end, she acts coldly and is about to lose the opportunity to marry until her feelings are proved otherwise when Hero gives Benedick a sonnet written by Beatrice’s hand. Even then, they still get married while displaying their wits (5.4.91-96)

2.2.1. The true lovers, Beatrice and Benedick

(http://www.movieforum.com/movies/titles/muchadoaboutnothing/beaben.shtml)

Beatrice and Benedick represent the deep, intelligent pairing in the play. They do not play by the rules of social decorum, and are constantly exchanging verbal daggers that mask a mutual affection towards each other. Unlike Hero and Claudio, Beatrice and Benedick have a past together, which is first deduced when Beatrice says: “You always end with a jade’s trick. I know you of old.” (1.1.138-139), and later confirmed by Beatrice herself:

DON PEDRO

Come, lady, come; you have lost the heart of
Signior Benedick.

BEATRICE

Indeed, my lord, he lent it me awhile; and I gave
him use for it, a double heart for his single one:
marry, once before he won it of me with false dice,
therefore your grace may well say I have lost it.

(2.1.253-258)

Their relationship is not based on solely on physical attraction or money, but also in romantical attraction. They are equals.

Their initial rejection of marriage is a mechanism of defense against their own desires, a view that is confirmed when they come to desire it after believing that the other loves them. As Claire McEachern says about Benedick, and this can be said about Beatrice too, he is “one who seems to protest too much, a character who seems to need the convention as a defence against his own impulse to the contrary.”

Claudio’s lack of trust towards Hero is complimented by Benedick’s trust towards Beatrice. Even when he has joked so much about cuckoldry, he is the only man of the company to stand by Hero’s side, and is willing to accept Beatrice’s request to challenge Claudio when she tells him that she is sure that her cousin has been wrongly accused by him. He has changed, he has been transformed by his love for Beatrice.

3. Basic ideas on marriage: property and virginity

October 17th, 2011

3.1. Marriage and property

People did not marry for love in Shakespeare’s times. Marriage was more of a transactional contract between families, so that both parts would result benefited economically or socially.

The main pair of lovers, Claudio and Hero, do not marry for love. Claudio “falls in love” with Hero on meeting her, but he wouldn’t have done so were she not the daughter of the noble Leonato di Messina. Claudio is attracted to Hero’s physical beauty and to his father’s riches.

Hero is treated as an object, as a possession. This is materialistic view is exemplified when Claudio praises Hero by asking: “Can the world buy such a jewel?” (1.1.171). Shortly after, Claudio asks whether Hero has any brother:

CLAUDIO

Hath Leonato any son, my lord?

DON PEDRO

No child but Hero; she’s his only heir.

(1.1.275)

This ensures that Hero will inherit the whole of her father’s wealth. Because the wife is the property of the husband, all of Hero’s property would belong to Claudio.

Dowry is alluded once more during the play when Benedick says about Beatrice: “I would not marry her, though she were endowed with all that Adam bad left him before he transgressed.” (2.1.229-231)

His statement confirms the idea of marriage as a business deal, as a way of providing financial and social security for the families involved.

Because the bride is a possession, it needs to be handed over to the husband by his current owner, her father. Before the Masque, and after Beatrice speaks against marriage, Leonato reminds Hero to accept the prince’s proposal if he woos her.

LEONATO

Daughter, remember what I told you: if the prince
do solicit you in that kind, you know your answer.

(2.1.58-60)

Beatrice jokes about Hero rejecting his suitor in favour of someone she likes. The idea is too ridiculous for Leonato to take it seriously.

When Don Pedro informs Leonato of Claudio’s intentions to marry his daughter, Leonato accepts his request and passes his daughter to him.

LEONATO

Count, take of me my daughter, and with her my
fortunes: his grace hath made the match, and an
grace say Amen to it.

(2.1.277-279)

Then permission is granted once again during the wedding:

CLAUDIO

Stand thee by, friar. Father, by your leave:
Will you with free and unconstrained soul
Give me this maid, your daughter?

LEONATO

As freely, son, as God did give her me.

CLAUDIO

And what have I to give you back, whose worth
May counterpoise this rich and precious gift?

DON PEDRO

Nothing, unless you render her again.

(4.1.21-27)

After Hero’s fake death, Leonato offers his nephew to Claudio, and makes it clear that “she alone is heir to both of us” (to Leonato himself and his brother Antonio).

3.2. The importance of virginity

(http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Claudio,_deceived_by_Don_John,_accuses_Hero_stone.jpg) 

Virginity before marriage is the main theme in Much Ado About Nothing, and the cause behind all the events that unfold.

One of the main reasons for the importance of virginity before marriage is summarized by Margaret Loftus Ranald:

“An unchaste woman lost her value on the marriage market; and if already married, she might corrupt the pure line of descent by insinuating a bastard into it. Consequently a young virgin was counselled to live before her marriage in an utterly chaste manner.” (qtd. in Green, 6)

An example of this corruption appears in the play in the figure of Don John, the bastard brother of Don Pedro of Aragon. Part of Don John’s villainry stems from his resentment towards his illigitimacy and the fact that he could never match up to the Prince’s position. However, the character of Don John is not as well traced as Edward’s in King Lear, who produces a whole monologue on the nature of heir legitimacy.

Returning to the central figure of Hero, she is attractive because she is virtuous in the eyes of everyone. Claudio makes sure of this by asking Benedick about her (1.1.154-170).

The honour and value of a woman lay in her chastity. Her family could lose its reputation and honour if the woman was proved to be unchaste. That’s why Leonato reacts to violently when Claudio publicly shames Hero in the wedding. His first reaction, out of fear, is to accuse Hero as well, not listening to her daughter’s claims:

LEONATO

Do not live, Hero; do not ope thine eyes:
For, did I think thou wouldst not quickly die,
Thought I thy spirits were stronger than thy shames,
Myself would, on the rearward of reproaches,
Strike at thy life.
(…)
But mine and mine I loved and mine I praised
And mine that I was proud on, mine so much
That I myself was to myself not mine,
Valuing of her,–why, she, O, she is fallen
Into a pit of ink, that the wide sea
Hath drops too few to wash her clean again
And salt too little which may season give
To her foul-tainted flesh!

(4.1.123-143)

Hero, and extensively his whole family, has been dishonoured. Being Hero is only heir, he has lost the opportunity to secure his family with a profitable marriage. The status of his family is badly damaged, almost dead:

LEONATO

Hath no man’s dagger here a point for me?

(4.1.109)

Leonato only considers the possibility that it had been a misunderstanding when Benedick suggests so. He shifts his rage towards her daughter to his willingness to seek justice in order to save their honour.

LEONATO

I know not. If they speak but truth of her,
These hands shall tear her; if they wrong her honour,
The proudest of them shall well hear of it.

(4.1.190-193)

It is not so much the act of having sex before marriage as the act of having sex with another man which brings dishonour, as Leonato’s willingness to forgive Claudio when he suspects that he may have lay with his daughter proves:

LEONATO

Dear my lord, if you, in your own proof,
Have vanquish’d the resistance of her youth,
And made defeat of her virginity,–

CLAUDIO

I know what you would say: if I have known her,
You will say she did embrace me as a husband,
And so extenuate the ‘forehand sin:
No, Leonato,
I never tempted her with word too large;
But, as a brother to his sister, show’d
Bashful sincerity and comely love.

(4.1.44-53)

Beatrice too is given credit by Benedick for being a virgin: “They say the lady is fair; ’tis a truth, I can bear them witness; and virtuous; ’tis so, I cannot reprove it.” (2.3.253-255)

    Personal
    Calendar
    November 2026
    M T W T F S S
     1
    2345678
    9101112131415
    16171819202122
    23242526272829
    30